From Knowing to Doing: A Memory-Controlled Benchmark for LLM Trading Agents on Stock Markets
By Taojie Zhu, Wentao Zhao, Rui Sun, Beidi Luan, Jiacheng Lu, Sinuo Wang, Jing Li, Daxin Jiang, Yonghong He, Zuo Bai
Rating
1339
Battle Count: 50
Relevance
9/10
Highly relevant to quantitative trading. The paper directly addresses how to evaluate LLM-based trading agents in stock markets, introduces realistic A-share execution constraints (T+1, price limits, fees), provides Barra-style factor attribution that decomposes returns into market, style, and selection alpha, and demonstrates that most LLM agents' returns are explained by passive factor exposure rather than genuine stock-selection skill. The factor exposure analysis (Table 8) reveals systematic differences between ML and LLM portfolio construction. The benchmark provides a rigorous framework for distinguishing skill from luck in automated trading.
Implementation Complexity
7/10
Moderate to high complexity. Requires: (1) Qlib-based execution engine with A-share market rules (T+1, price limits, board-specific thresholds); (2) Four-level masking protocol with alias maps and tool-level re-masking; (3) Barra-style cross-sectional regression with VIF-screened factors; (4) ReAct-style agent loop with six tools and JSON action schema; (5) Multi-seed evaluation infrastructure; (6) De-anonymization probe framework. The masking protocol and attribution layer are the most novel components. Vendor API integration and provider-neutral adapters add engineering complexity.
Reproducibility
5/5
The authors explicitly state they release KTD-FIN as a reproducible template including environment, scripts, masking and probe protocols, and the full evaluation dataset. The harness is deterministic given a seed, and all models are re-evaluable on identical conditions. Provider-neutral tool-call normalization is implemented. Full hyperparameters, prompts, and configuration tables are provided in appendices.
About this paper
Methodology: KTD-FIN (Knowing-To-Doing Financial Benchmark). Problem types: Portfolio Optimization, Algorithmic Trading, Benchmarking and Evaluation, Factor Models, Risk Management, Natural Language Processing.
The interactive Everscope explorer (charts, battles, favorites) loads below.