Common Signals, Spurious Cross-Excitation, and Identification in Multivariate Hawkes Processes

By Jiwon Jung, Kiseop Lee

Rating

1833
Battle Count: 50

Relevance

9/10
Highly relevant for high-frequency trading and market microstructure analysis. It warns against interpreting fitted Hawkes cross-excitation coefficients as causal interaction when latent common factors (e.g., market-wide news or liquidity shocks) are present. This affects strategy backtesting, risk attribution, and the interpretation of 'contagion' or 'leadership' in financial networks.

Implementation Complexity

8/10
High complexity due to the need for spectral factorization, handling of latent variables, and implementation of Whittle estimation with sandwich standard errors. Requires advanced statistical programming skills.

Reproducibility

3/5
The paper provides detailed mathematical derivations, simulation parameters, and data sources (Binance public data). However, no direct link to a code repository is provided in the text, though the methodology is fully described for replication.

Abstract

Multivariate Hawkes models are widely used to measure endogenous interactions in event data, but latent common signals can generate apparent excitation even without structural interaction. We characterize the resulting linear projection and construct stable, nonnegative Hawkes processes that share the mean intensity and Bartlett spectrum of common-signal models despite having different excitation mechanisms. This establishes a concrete form of second-order non-identification. We derive integrated third-order cumulants for Hawkes processes with Cox immigration and establish generic local identification of normalized structural parameters in two- and three-dimensional systems. An exact-equivalence Monte Carlo experiment demonstrates how third-order information can distinguish mechanisms with identical second-order structure, while revealing substantial finite-sample limitations under weak signals. For a restricted parametric family, we develop Whittle estimation from binned counts, establish consistency and asymptotic normality under appropriate identification conditions, and construct feasible sandwich standard errors accounting for estimated mean intensities. Simulations assess structural recovery and inference accuracy. An application to cryptocurrency transactions illustrates the sensitivity of inferred excitation to model specification and the limitations of structural interpretation based on spectral fit alone.

The interactive Everscope explorer (charts, battles, favorites) loads below.